Two budgeting styles in one app

Monarch offers two ways to budget. Category budgeting sets a limit for each category, such as groceries, restaurants or utilities. Flex budgeting groups spending into three buckets, fixed, flexible and non-monthly, and focuses on one number: how much is left for flexible spending. Monarch's blog calls flex one of its core budgeting types and says you can switch between category and flex budgets in the budget settings.

Transactions are still categorized the same way in both styles. What changes is what you are asked to plan and watch: twenty separate limits, or one flexible total plus a set of committed costs.

This is research from official pages read on 30 October 2026, not firsthand testing. We have not opened these accounts or run the features described; help pages change, so confirm the live page before you rely on a detail.

The three buckets and goals

These definitions and examples come from Monarch's flex budgeting post, originally published 17 November 2024 and updated 30 April 2026.

The three buckets and goals
BucketMonarch's descriptionMonarch's examples
FixedYour most predictable expenses, paid each monthHousing, insurance, loan minimums, subscriptions, utilities, phone, recurring charitable giving, childcare
Non-monthlyBigger expenses that come at least once a year but not every monthTaxes, gifts, car and home repairs, travel, annual donations and subscriptions, annual or semiannual insurance
FlexibleHardest to predict, easiest to controlGroceries, gas, medical copays, shopping, restaurants, entertainment, hobbies
GoalsThe bigger life targets you save or invest toward for a whileEmergency fund, retirement contributions, paying down debt above 25% interest, education savings, big purchases

Worked example: converting a 20-category budget

This invented household takes home $7,000 a month and currently budgets 20 categories. Converting to flex means assigning each category to a bucket, turning yearly costs into monthly set-asides, and moving savings into goals. Nothing about the household's spending changes; only the number they watch does.

Fixed categories total $3,745: rent $2,100, car payment $380, car insurance $140, utilities $210, phone $90, internet $70, childcare $650, streaming $45 and gym $60. Non-monthly set-asides total $485: car registration $20 (from $240 a year), holiday gifts $75 ($900 a year), travel $200 ($2,400 a year), repairs $100 ($1,200 a year) and medical deductible $90 ($1,080 a year). Goals total $900: $500 to the emergency fund and $400 to retirement. The six flexible categories (groceries $900, dining $300, gas $220, shopping $250, entertainment $120 and personal care $80) total $1,870.

Flex number: $7,000 minus $3,745 minus $485 minus $900 equals $1,870 a month, or about $434.88 a week using Monarch's 4.3 divisor. Instead of six flexible limits, the household watches one: if dining runs $100 over, groceries or shopping have to come in $100 under for the month to stay on plan.

Worked example: converting a 20-category budget
BucketCategoriesMonthly amount
Fixed9$3,745
Non-monthly5$485
Goals2 contributions$900
Flexible (flex number)6$1,870
Total20 categories plus goals$7,000

When each style suits a household

Monarch's own comparison is candid about the trade-off. Flex is less work to plan and gives room in how money is spent but less detail about where it goes; category budgeting gives detail but its strict limits can feel rigid.

When each style suits a household
Choose flex ifChoose category if
Previous budgets did not stickYou want to learn about and manage your spending
You have little time for budgetingYou want to track certain expenses for tax purposes
You do not want to track every expense in detail and spend less than you earnYou are actively trying to cut your spending overall
Spending varies a lot month to monthYou prefer cash envelope budgeting

Setting the flex number and common mistakes

Monarch says it calculates the flex number automatically once your buckets and goals are set up, and that you can also work it out by hand with its formula. For variable income its post advises recalculating the flex number each month, using expected income as the baseline. A practical starting point of our own: compare the result with what your flexible categories actually cost over the last three months before you commit to it.

  • Misfiled fixed costs: a subscription left in Flexible makes the flex number look smaller than it is; move it to Fixed in Settings, Categories.
  • Non-monthly without rollover: if rollover is not enabled on a non-monthly category, unspent set-asides do not carry forward and the bill arrives with nothing saved.
  • Goals left out: if goal contributions are not subtracted, the flex number quietly includes your savings.
  • Over-reading weekly figures: the 4.3 divisor is an average of about 4.33 weeks a month, so a month that contains five of your usual shopping days will run tighter than the weekly figure suggests.

Questions before you decide

How is the flex number calculated?

Monarch's blog gives the formula: income minus fixed expenses minus non-monthly expenses minus goals equals the monthly flex number. For a weekly figure it divides by 4.3, because 52 weeks divided by 12 months is about 4.33.

Can I change which bucket a category is in?

Yes. Monarch says it sorts categories into the three buckets automatically, and that in Settings, Categories you can reorder which categories go in which bucket, disable unused ones or add new ones.

How do non-monthly expenses work?

Monarch describes rollover as an optional setting on each category that carries unspent money into the next month, so a non-monthly category can build up like a sinking fund. It also mentions a variable frequency for irregular items and setting amounts up to two years ahead.

Is flex budgeting less accurate than category budgeting?

It gives less detail about where variable money goes, which Monarch's own comparison acknowledges. It still tracks every transaction by category; it just budgets the flexible ones as a single total.

Follow the sources

Provider terms can change. Recheck the linked source before applying or subscribing.

Browse the free decision worksheets